Vital Football

Latest Cardiff City News

Are Cardiff City Wasting Good Squad Options?

Are Cardiff City Wasting Good Squad Options?

Cardiff City do have a relatively small squad, and have relied heavily on a select group of players to continue the play-off push, even after the gruelling exploits of the Carling Cup. It`s abundantly clear that Malky Mackay is not happy with the depth of squad available to him, and several players he inherited from the Dave Jones era have been largely sidelined.

However, despite the claims of a small squad, Cardiff City are able to put our two starting XI`s which would surely be very competitive in the Championship. Mackay`s favoured formation and line-up is as below:


McNaughton, Hudson, Turner, Taylor


Cowie, Gunnarsson, Whittingham



This is a narrow formation, with no natural width. With Kenny Miller up front on his own, we need the midfield to be creative, support him in the box and to get Joe Mason on the ball in dangerous areas. This gameplan has been excellent at times, but looked ineffective since the turn of the year.

The players left-out of that line-up, however, fit very nicely into a conventional 4-4-2 system and you`d have to wonder which would triumph over the other given current form, fitness and confidence.


Quinn, Gerrard, Blake, Naylor

Harris, Kiss, Ralls, Conway

Gestede, Earnshaw

The above 'second XI` has a very balanced feel to it, with natural players on the flanks in Harris and Conway. Winger Harris is pacy, unpredictable and raw while wideman Conway is a clever footballer and accurate crosser rather than a winger. Up-front is the little-and-large combination that has proved successful for decades. Crucially, every player knows their roles and responsibilities. The back four all have significant experience at this level, while Kiss, Ralls and Conway in midfield have all impressed at times this season before falling completely out of favour!

I think the above illustrates that Malky Mackay has become too reliant on individuals like Miller, Whittingham and Cowie. None of whom fit perfectly into our systems. Whitts is phenomenal on his day, most effective in a central area - but does he have the physique to play in a midfield two? Malky thinks not. Miller is a goalscorer, but not a target man and needs support. His form has suffered badly. Cowie has a fantastic engine, but does not offer enough in a central role, and does not appear comfortable on the right wing. Can we afford an 'extra man` in midfield?

Cardiff City fans will notice that on-loan midfielder Liam Lawrence did not make it into either XI. He is currently in favour, and did well against Millwall but he looks best on the right side of midfield - again not fitting in with our current system.

Malky Mackay has a clear idea of what he wants, and trusts his favoured personnel to deliver it. It does seem to me that we have alternative options, incredibly useful when form or confidence dips/fatigue hits, but have perhaps not utilised the squad to its maximum potential.

One thing noticeable with both formations is that neither looks at their strongest in the final third - presumably hence our recent lack of goals !

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Tuesday April 3 2012
Time: 10:00AM

Login to post a comment

Recent Cardiff City Articles

Vital Pre-Match - Championship, 21st-22nd October

The 2016-17 season continues with the latest round of matches this weekend, which will see us among those having a match in this upcoming schedule with three-points the aim of course.

Match Day Officials v Nott'm Forest (22/10/16)

The Football League have now announced the Match Day officials that will take charge of the game against Nottingham Forest this Saturday.

Cardiff 1-1 Sheffield Wednesday - Highlights

Cardiff drew with Sheffield Wednesday in the Championship on Wednesday.

Vital View - Championship, 18th-19th October

Newcastle took over at the top ahead of Norwich, Brighton closed in going up to third. A first Blackburn win was secured with another Rotherham defeat costing Alan Stubbs his job.

Archived Vital Cardiff Articles

Vital Cardiff articles from

Site Journalists

Whittingham's Left Peg
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Nottingham Forest v Cardiff
Suggested By:
Cardiff win0%
Nottingham Forest win0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 13 9 1 3 28 16
2 Norwich 13 8 3 2 27 8
3 Brighton 13 7 4 2 25 8
4 Huddersfield 13 8 1 4 25 3
5 Birmingham 14 6 5 3 23 3
6 Sheff Wed 13 6 3 4 21 0
7 Bristol City 13 6 2 5 20 5
8 Brentford 13 5 4 4 19 7
9 Q.P.R. 13 5 4 4 19 -2
10 Reading 13 5 4 4 19 -4
11 Fulham 13 4 6 3 18 -1
12 Ipswich 13 4 5 4 17 1
13 Burton 14 4 5 5 17 0
14 Preston 13 5 2 6 17 0
15 Leeds Utd 13 5 2 6 17 -2
16 Barnsley 13 5 1 7 16 1
17 Wolves 13 4 4 5 16 0
18 Forest 13 4 3 6 15 -2
19 Aston Villa 13 2 8 3 14 -1
20 Derby County 13 3 5 5 14 -3
21 Blackburn 13 3 3 7 12 -7
22 Cardiff 13 3 3 7 12 -10
23 Wigan 13 2 5 6 11 -2
24 Rotherham 13 1 3 9 6 -18
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Cardiff City Results (view all)

Cardiff City Fixtures (view all)

Oct 22 2016 5:30PM : Nottingham Forest (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Oct 29 2016 3:00PM : Wigan Athletic (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 5 2016 3:00PM : Newcastle United (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 19 2016 3:00PM : Huddersfield Town (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 26 2016 3:00PM : Aston Villa (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 3 2016 3:00PM : Brighton & Hove Albion (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Vital Football Comment