Date:Friday August 19 2011
Cardiff City would seem to have an abundance of riches in the centre-half position but the case for quality over quantity cerrtainly applies with a lack of positional awareness and a sloppy defensive performance on show against Brighton & Hove Albion on Wednesday.
It's very harsh to judge a new team so early on, but the Championship is notoriously unforgiving and aspects that aren't working need to be changed before too many points are lost.
Mark Hudson and Anthony Gerrard are both establised and experienced Championship defenders. Hudson showed fine form at times last season, while Gerrard was named player of the year on-loan at Hull City. However, doubts remain as to the two players as a partnership with a lack of pace and mobility underlying the concerns.
Both Gerrard and Hudson are 'blockers' of the Scott Young mould. Powerful and strong, aiming to win the physical battles against their opponents. Many feel that both would be more comfortable alongside a more classy centre-half with pace to cover behind, a job that Danny Gabbidon once filled so successfully for City. Distribution from the back remains a weakness and too often we wasted posession and found ourselves under un-necessary pressure.
Unfortunately, pacy, ball-playing centres halves with the ability to stand-up to the rigours of the Championship are hard to come by.
If the Hudson/Gerrard partnership does not gel, Israeli Dekel Keinan is surely next in line and has already proved a decent foil for Hudson last year. Keinan arrived from Blackpool in January, and featured heavily in our run-in putting in some impressive performances before enduring a ngihtmare end to the season and conceding a needless penalty in our 3-0 Reading defeat.
Keinan is more mobile than Hudson or Gerrard, and is also reasonably strong in the air. Where he certainly outclasses Mackay's other defensive options is in passing and distribution. Keinan was always willing to receive possession last year, looking to get on the ball and pick out a midfielder, rather than look for Bothroyd or try an ambitious cross-field pass. His control and composure may be a bonus, especially give then midfield balance and target man we are currently lacking.
Gabor Gyepes' days at the club look to be numbered, while Darcy Blake is also a potential option. Despite all these options, Mackay has not ruled out a move for another centre-half and enquired about Nottingham Forest's new captain Luke chambers.
It seems certain that Mackay will stick to the same starting XI as the Brighton defeat - However, if the Hudson/Gerrard combination remains un-easy - Dekel Keinan is surely the man to step in, and sooner ratehr than later.
Vital Cardiff is now available on both facebook and twitter, so if you are that way inclined and more importantly understand all this new fangled dangled stuff, feel free to watch us, poke us or whatever else you are meant to do there!
Vital Cardiff on: or
Date:Friday August 19 2011
Vital Report: Cardiff 2 Reading 1 (Saturday November 22 2014)
Stats: Cardiff v Reading (Friday November 21 2014)
Vital Preview: Cardiff v Reading (Friday November 21 2014)
Alfie Will Come Good (Friday November 21 2014)
Slade Expecting Tough Reading Clash (Thursday November 20 2014)
Mackay Returns (Thursday November 20 2014)
Pilkington Opens Irish Account (Wednesday November 19 2014)
Final Day Fixtures Set (Tuesday November 18 2014)
Make Or Break For Morrison (Sunday November 16 2014)
Vital Report: Birmingham 0 Cardiff 0 (Monday November 10 2014)
|13. Sheff Wed||18||4||10||4||-2||22|
|Video: Brighton Highlights
» Norwich : 24/11/2014 12:00:00
|Norwich 3 Brighton 3 (Report)
» Brighton : 24/11/2014 11:53:00
|Jackett to approach Leicester
» Wolves : 24/11/2014 11:00:00
|The Valley of Despair
» Charlton : 24/11/2014 10:30:00
|Watch Jacob Murphy's Cracking Free Kick
» Norwich : 24/11/2014 10:28:00